Law MonitorLaw MonitorLaw Monitor
  • Home
  • News
  • LAW Notes
    • CLAT / CUET
    • Hindu Law
    • Muslim law
    • Administrative Law Notes: JUDICIARY NOTES
    • ICA 1872
    • evidence act 2023
  • BA LLB NOTES
    • Political Science
    • Ballb/LLB Sample Paper-DBRAU
    • History
  • Legal Maxims
  • My Laws
  • Bare Acts Download
  • Blog
  • Hindi Posts
Notification Show More
Font ResizerAa
Law MonitorLaw Monitor
Font ResizerAa
  • Home
  • History
  • Bookmarks
  • News
  • My Laws
  • CLAT / CUET
  • Legal Maxims
  • Blog
  • Home
  • News
  • LAW Notes
    • CLAT / CUET
    • Hindu Law
    • Muslim law
    • Administrative Law Notes: JUDICIARY NOTES
    • ICA 1872
    • evidence act 2023
  • BA LLB NOTES
    • Political Science
    • Ballb/LLB Sample Paper-DBRAU
    • History
  • Legal Maxims
  • My Laws
  • Bare Acts Download
  • Blog
  • Hindi Posts
Follow US
Law Monitor > Blog > Administrative Law > Judicial Control of Administrative Discretion- Delegation of Discretion
Administrative Law

Judicial Control of Administrative Discretion- Delegation of Discretion

Last updated: 14/04/2024 8:40 am
By Admin 303 Views
Share
7 Min Read
Judicial Control of Administrative Discretion- Delegation of Discretion
Judicial Control of Administrative Discretion- Delegation of Discretion
SHARE

We are going to discover the essence of administrative discretion and its judicial oversight, exploring its necessity, control mechanisms, and the role of courts in ensuring accountable governance.

Contents
Understanding Administrative DiscretionNEED OF ADMINISTRATIVE DISCRETIONJudicial Control of Administrative DiscretionJudicial Control of DelegationInvalidity of Delegated Legislation

Understanding Administrative Discretion

Discretion means the liberty to act according to one’s pleasure, or at one’s own will.

Administrative discretion refers to the freedom given to government officials to make decisions based on their judgment. In modern democracies, it’s common for governments to grant such powers to officials. However, to prevent misuse of this authority, there needs to be oversight.

Justice Douglas once stated“where discretion is absolute, man has always suffered…Absolute discretion…is more destructive of freedom than any of man’s other inventions.”

NEED OF ADMINISTRATIVE DISCRETION

Governments rely on administrative discretion to handle various tasks efficiently. For instance, in providing services like education, healthcare, and social welfare, there are countless details that can’t be covered by laws alone. This is where discretion comes in handy.

 In the words of Prof. H. W.R. Wade,
“If the state is to care for its citizens from the cradle to the grave, to protect their environment, to educate them at all stages, to provide them with employment, training, houses, medical services, pensions and in the last resort food, clothing and shelter, it needs a huge administrative apparatus. Relatively little can be done by merely passing Acts of Parliament and leaving it to the courts to enforce them. There are far too many problems of detail and far too many matters which cannot be decided in advance. No one may erect a building without planning permission, but no system of general rules can prescribe for every case. There must be discretionary power.”

Judicial Control of Administrative Discretion

To ensure fair use of administrative discretion, there must be checks and balances. While India’s Constitution doesn’t follow the strict separation of powers like the U.S., there’s still a general division between legislative, administrative, and judicial functions.

There are various grounds on which the judiciary will have to intervene in the exercise of discretionary power for judicial control administrative discretion. These grounds include:

(i) Abuse of discretionary power: When discretionary power is conferred on authority, it must be exercised following the law. As Markose put it, “When the mode of exercising a valid power is improper or unreasonable, there is an abuse of power.” There are certain circumstances from which abuse or excess of discretionary power can be inferred. These may be acting without jurisdiction, exceeding jurisdiction, an arbitrary action, mala fide actions, improper motive, unreasonableness, non-observance of principles of natural justice, etc.

Read Also

First Time Ever: Tamil Nadu Govt Implements 10 Laws After Supreme Court Declares ‘Deemed Assent’ by Governor
BNS 64 Case: इलाहाबाद उच्च न्यायालय ने बलात्कार के लिए पीड़िता को ‘जिम्मेदार’ बताया, आरोपी को जमानत दी

(ii) Non-exercise of discretion: judicial control administrative discretion, as non-exercise of discretion arises either

(a) When the authority delegates his power to a subordinate without any statutory authority, or

- Advertisement -

(b) When someone acts under dictation from superiors without any statutory authority.

The proper test of deciding whether a delegation is valid or not is to see if the authority who delegates had the power to so delegate. If they did, then the action is valid and justified, but if they did not, the action should be invalid and unlawful.

Judicial Control of Administrative Discretion- Delegation of Discretion
Judicial Control of Administrative Discretion- Delegation of Discretion

Judicial Control of Delegation

  • When a statute grants discretionary power to an administrative authority without explicitly allowing delegation, only that authority can exercise the discretion. Delegating this power further to another person or entity goes against the principle of “delegatus non potest delegare” (a delegate cannot delegate).
  • In the case of Vine v. National Dock Labour Board, the House of Lords invalidated the dismissal of a dock worker because the Dock Labour Board, to whom the power was given, had passed the decision to a disciplinary committee instead of deciding it themselves.

Invalidity of Delegated Legislation

  1. Ultra Vires Enabling Act: If a law contradicts the constitution, it’s considered “ultra vires.” This may challenge the legislature’s authority to enact such laws or serve as a check on their powers. There are limits to delegation, and essential legislative powers cannot be delegated.
  2. Violation of Constitutional Provisions: Sometimes, the enabling act might not violate the constitution, but the subordinate legislation does. The same principles used to assess the constitutionality of laws directly from the parliament apply to subordinate laws. If a rule under the enabling act breaches constitutional provisions, only that rule is invalidated, not the entire act.
  3. Ultra Vires of Delegating Act: Delegated powers must align with the terms set by the legislature. If the rules exceed the scope of authority granted by the legislature, they can be challenged as ultra vires. Subordinate delegation should not contradict or conflict with the delegating act.

By understanding these principles, we ensure that administrative discretion serves the public interest without undermining democratic principles.

- Advertisement -

FAQs:

What is Administrative Discretion?

Administrative discretion refers to the freedom given to government officials to make decisions based on their judgment. In modern democracies, it’s common for governments to grant such powers to officials.

What is NEED OF ADMINISTRATIVE DISCRETION?

Governments rely on administrative discretion to handle various tasks efficiently. For instance, in providing services like education, healthcare, and social welfare, there are countless details that can’t be covered by laws alone.

Judicial Control of Administrative Discretion

There are various grounds on which the judiciary will have to intervene in the exercise of discretionary power for judicial control administrative discretion.

(i) Abuse of discretionary power

(ii) Non-exercise of discretion

TAGGED:administrative lawlawnotes
Share This Article
Facebook Twitter Whatsapp Whatsapp Copy Link Print
Leave a Comment Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe Newsletter

Loading

Read Also:

Budget 2025: Full Schedule, Live Streaming Details, and How to Watch on Mobile

As Budget Day approaches, here’s a quick look at the key events…

Electoral Bonds: SC Refuses To Direct Disclosure Of Information Of 2018

The Supreme Court declined to mandate the disclosure of electoral bond information…

What is a State? Definition, Elements of State

Aristotle, who is regarded as Father of Political Science. According to him,…

You Might Also Like

News

26/11 के आरोपी तहव्वुर राणा को मिलेगी निष्पक्ष सुनवाई: नई दिल्ली बार एसोसिएशन का भरोसा

By Admin
News

The Waqf (Amendment) Bill, 2025: Key Provisions

By Admin
LAWYERS in British India: ROLES AND FUNCTIONS
CLAT / CUET

LAWYERS in British India: ROLES AND FUNCTIONS

By Admin
Hindi

कथित बलात्कार पीड़िता को मेडिकल जांच से इनकार करने पर केस पर पड़ सकता है असर: सुप्रीम कोर्ट

By Admin
Law Monitor is an online resource for legal professionals providing comprehensive coverage of the latest news related to law. Aso notes for BaLLB and LLB Students. Its timely notifications make it easy to keep up with the ever-changing landscape of legal discourse. Law Monitor is an invaluable resource for those actively involved in legislation or legal matters.
Facebook Twitter Pinterest Youtube Instagram
Check also
  • Home
  • Web Stories
  • Image Compressor Online Tool
  • Current Affairs
  • Bare Acts Download
  • Blog
FacebookLike
InstagramFollow
TelegramFollow
More Info
  • Contact
  • Newsletter
  • Saved / History
Join Telegram For Notes

Law Monitor © Copyright 2024, All Rights Reserved

Join Us!
Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss our latest news, podcasts etc.

Loading
Zero spam, Unsubscribe at any time.